MOBILE, Ala. (WALA) - A 90-page ruling from the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals addresses several challenges raised by Lam Luong's defense lawyers.
The ruling's release follows an appeals court decision to overturn Lam Luong's capital murder conviction. In 2009, Luong was sentenced to death for throwing his four small children from the Dauphin Island bridge.
Four of five justices agreed with the defense, stating the circuit court judge "erred" in denying a motion to move the trial outside Mobile County.
Former District Attorney John Tyson Junior disagrees and said the decision came after much consideration.
"Judge Graddick didn't just summarily dismiss the motion from the defense. We argued about it, and decided that the best way to proceed with that would be to ask jurors whether or not they could be fair and impartial and then make judgments, both prosecution, defense and court as to whether or not we seat a fair and impartial jury. And it was after we talked to them that the judge decided once in for all that we could in fact do that and go forward," Tyson said.
The defense also raised questions about the state's interpreter. Tyson said that was an issue that had never been brought up before.
"Don't forget this man speaks English and we did get an interpreter and, to the best of my memory, we didn't have one complaint, one suggestion that the interpreter was somehow or another inadequate," he said. "It never came up."
The appeals court also said the judge should have granted Luong's lawyers $7,500 to travel to Vietnam to gather information about Luong's childhood, as part of his defense.
One appeals judge also said it was mistake for jurors to be shown a videotape of a detective throwing bags off the Dauphin island Bridge as a re-enactment of the crime.
"None of them change the facts of this case. And I think, ultimately, none of them are going to change the results of this case. But we now have more steps to go, long appeals, expensive appeals, and maybe we even have to start all over again," Tyson said.
The Appeals Court did rule against the defense on one issue, saying there was "absolutely no evidence" that police placed undue pressure on Luong to confess.
Mobile police have released the names of three shooting victims. Police say the shooting was the result of domestic violence.
Mobile Police have launched an internal investigation into the Third Precinct Captain and a patrol officer, who authorities believe were involved in an ongoing sexual relationship. Captain Carla Longmire is charged with conduct unbecoming …
A Grand Bay family woke up to an unexpected guest on their back porch Wednesday, December 11 - a donkey. Don Edeker said the little guy is lost, and he's trying to help his owner find him.
You've heard about some brazen criminals and what they will do to get what they want. This time, you are going to hear about a brave bank employee who didn't mind saying "no".
Augusta Evans School is scheduled to move to a new location in the Spring. But according the City of Mobile, the city operated after-school program at will not be moving to the same location.
The City of Fairhope is considering raising property taxes to better fund their schools. This means Fairhope Public Schools will be put in their own tax district, even though they are still part of the Baldwin County School System.